Alligator Reef Club
Popular Dishes
Four variations. bloody mary, avo and onion, nashville blt, devil nicoise
$14.00
*fresh ahi tuna tossed in house made ponzu sauce, jasmine rice, sliced cucumber, seaweed salad, red cabbage, shredded carrots, sriracha aioli, black sesame.
$17.00
A florida keys staple. we fry them to a crisp golden brown and serve them with a house made cajun remoulade.
$12.00
Eggroll stuffed with caribbean spiced alligator, superfoods slaw, fresh sweet peppers and red onion. served with tiger aioli
$16.00
Blend of tomatoes, onion, roasted garlic and green olives, tossed in olive oil and served over grilled focaccia with fresh basil.
$12.00
Menu for Alligator Reef Club
freshies
strawberry fields forevertito"s handmade vodka and fresh strawberry lemonade topped with prosecco and served with a strawberry popsicle" | $12.00 |
lavender lemonadetito | - |
morada bay muletito | - |
matecumbe mai taipapa pilar blonde rum, fresh lime juice, fresh orange juice, monin orgeat syrup, papa pilar dark rum and garnished with mint sprig | $12.00 |
strawberry fields forevertito"s handmade vodka and fresh strawberry lemonade topped with prosecco and served with a strawberry popsicle" | $13.00 |
lavender lemonadetito | - |
strawberry fieltito"s handmade strawberry lemon and served with a" | - |
lavender lemontito"s handmade tea and housema garnished with le sub bulldog gin fi" | - |
morada bay multito"s handmade v and fresh blackbe topped with fresh mint sprig" | - |
matecumbe maipapa pilar blonde juice, fresh oran orgeat syrup, pap garnished with mi | - |
fl75our take on classic bulldog gin, orang strained, topped w | $12.00 |
lime in the cocopapa pilar blonde fresh muddled min soda water. | - |
conch countryjameson orange, c muddled orange a fresh ginger beer | - |
mooth agave drinks
atermalonepolon tequila silver, fresh watermelon ice, fresh lime juice, soda water | $13.00 |
rple cactusdisse tequila monin cherry | $13.00 |
stirred
capri spritzitalicus bergamotto liqueur, mionetto prosecco, fresh lemon sour club soda, garnished with orange slice and mint sprig | $11.00 |
italian jobelijah craig small batch bourbon | $14.00 |
breakfast old fashionrussell | - |
florida"s citrus southside"bulldog gin, fresh victor three citrus & mint leaf, simple syrup, orange slice, club soda, garnished with mint | $13.00 |
capri spritzitalicus bergamotto liqueur, mionetto prosecco, fresh lemon sour club soda, garnished with orange slice and mint sprig | $11.00 |
breakfast old fashionrussell | - |
capri spritzitalicus bergamotto liqueur, mionetto prosecco, fresh lemon sour club soda, garnished with orange slice and mint sprig | $11.00 |
breakfast old fashionrussell | - |
capri spritzitalicus bergamotto liqueur, mionetto prosecco, fresh lemon sour club soda, garnished with orange slice and mint sprig | $11.00 |
breakfast old fashionrussell | - |
martinis
bruschetta martinitrue premium italian vodka, splash of cinzano dry vermouth, garnished with cherry tomato and basil, garlic salted rim | $13.00 |
espresso martinitrue premium italian vodka, mr. black coffee liqueur, freshly brewed espresso, simple syrup | $13.00 |
mudded cucumbertito | - |
cherry good thymestoll raspberry, st-germain elderflower liqueur, fresh lemon sour, garnished with lemon and thyme | $13.00 |
espresso martinitito | - |
bayside blueberry bliss martinitito | - |
key lime kiss martinistoll vanilla, lime agave, monin key lime pie, coconut real, graham cracker rim - lime wheel | $13.00 |
morada bay muletito | - |
matecumbe mai taipapa pilar blonde rum, fresh lime juice, fresh orange juice, monin orgeat syrup, papa pilar dark rum and garnished with mint sprig | $12.00 |
fl75our take on classic french 75 bulldog gin, orange marmalade shaken and strained, topped with champagne | $12.00 |
lime in the coconut mojitopapa pilar blonde rum, real coconut purée, fresh muddled mint and lime, topped with soda water. | $13.00 |
conch country mulejameson orange, orange juice, muddled orange and mint, fresh ginger beer | $12.00 |
cherry good thymestoll® raspberry, st-germain elderflower liqueur, fresh lemon sour, garnished with lemon and thyme | $13.00 |
espresso martinitito | - |
bayside blueberry bliss martinitito | - |
key lime kiss martinistoll® vanilla, lime agave, monin key lime pie, coconut real, graham cracker rim - lime wheel | $13.00 |
cherry good thxmestoll" respberry; st-germaln eldertlower liqueur; fresh lemon sour, garnished with lemon and thyme | $13.00 |
espresso martinitito $ handmade vodke; mr; black coffee liqueur; freshly brewed espresso, simple syrup | $13.00 |
bayside blueberry bliss martinetito $ handmade vodke, fresh muddled blueberries, simple syrup, iime egave, lemon sour, with sugared rim | $18.00 |
key lime kiss martinistoll" vanllle, llme agave, monin key lime pie; coconut real, graham cracker rim lime wheel | $13.00 |
smooth agave drinks
watermelon ranch waterespolon tequila silver, fresh watermelon juice, fresh lime juice, sparkling water, watermelon garnish | $13.00 |
smoking bananabosscal joven mezcal, monin banana syrup, fresh lime, agave, garnished with cinnamon sugar rim & lime wheel | $12.00 |
purple cactusespolon blanco tequila, monin cherry smash syrup, fresh citrus pear and pomegranate juice, garnished with a lime | $13.00 |
rosy palomacalirosa tequila, agave syrup, lime juice, pink grapefruit juice, splash club soda, garnished with grapefruit | $13.00 |
fiesta key margespolón tequila silver, mango purée, fresh lime juice, agave, grand marnier floater | $13.00 |
endless summer margespolon tequila silver, watermelon juice, fresh lime juice, agave, muddled jalapeño | $13.00 |
watermalonespolon tequila silver, fresh watermelon juice, fresh lime juice, soda water | $13.00 |
urple cactusspolon blanco tequila, monin cherry nash syrup, fresh citrus pear and pomegranate juice, garnished with a lime | $13.00 |
sy palomapolon tequila, agave syrup, lime juice, k grapefruit juice, splash club soda, nished with grapefruit | $13.00 |
ta key marglòn tequila silver, mango purée, h lime juice, agave, d marnier floater | $13.00 |
ess summer margon tequila silver, watermelon juice, lime juice, agave, ed jalapeño | $13.00 |
watermalonespolon tequila silver, fresh watermelon juice, fresh lime juice, soda water | $13.00 |
urple cactusspolon blanco tequila, monin cherry nash syrup, fresh citrus pear and pomegranate juice, garnished with a lime | $13.00 |
sy palomaspolon tequila, agave syrup, lime juice, & grapefruit juice, splash club soda, garnished with grapefruit | $13.00 |
ta key margspolon tequila silver, mango purée, lime juice, agave, & marnier floater | $13.00 |
ess summer margspolon tequila silver, watermelon juice, lime juice, agave, & jalapeño | $13.00 |
small plates
elote corn ribsbutter poached, fire grilled corn, latin spiced aioli, cilantro, cotija, lime | $12.00 |
bahia bruschettatomato, basil, garlic, balsamic, served with grilled rosemary focaccia bread | $10.00 |
southernmost tuna pokefresh tuna, balsamic ponzu, black sesame, seaweed salad, scallion, wonton crisps | $18.00 |
tapas
flight of deviled egg | $13.00 |
alligator death roll | $17.00 |
gator bite | $14.00 |
two beef slider | $14.00 |
ahi tuna nacho | $16.00 |
sliced hanger steak | $14.00 |
hot honey scallophot honey glazed | $17.00 |
drunken musseltequilla based broth, garlic,lime, cilantro chili crisp,topped with grated cotija | $14.00 |
ahi tuna steakthinly sliced ahi tuna, lightly seared, | $17.00 |
for $13 or 7 for | $17.00 |
ight of deviled eggs +ales videppercurri & canidied bacor e5 vii tobiko rob srirachae scallioni | $13.00 |
alligator death roll *eggrol filledviithcapibbeari | $17.00 |
gator bitetenderized caribbean spiced alligator fried in a licht batter served witha spicy remoulade | $14.00 |
wo beef sliderri-blend beef, carmalized onion, | $14.00 |
ahi tuna nachowonton chips ahi tuna, ponzu, | $16.00 |
sliced hanger steak | $14.00 |
honey scallop | $17.00 |
prunken mussel | $14.00 |
ahi tuna steak | $17.00 |
for $13 or 7 for | $17.00 |
pinot noir
carmel roadpinot noir, california | $35.00 |
siduripinot noir, willamette valley, oregon | $55.00 |
interesting whites
terra d"oro moscato"california | $10.00 |
seaglass rieslingcalifornia | $8.00 |
bieler dry roseprovence france | $10.00 |
reds
pinot noircarmel road, california | $10.00 |
pinot noirsiduri, willamette valley, oregon | $35.00 |
merlotmurphy goode, california | $9.00 |
merlotdecoy, california | $32.00 |
cabernetjosh, california | $9.00 |
cabernetjoel gott, california | $12.00 |
cabernetrodney strong reserve, sonoma, california | $45.00 |
interesting reds
conundrum red blendcalifornia | $9.00 |
red schoonermalbec, argentina | $10.00 |
antigal malbecmendoza, argentina | $37.00 |
conundrum red blendinteresting reds, california | $32.00 |
red schoonerinteresting reds, malbec, argentina | $55.00 |
antigal malbecinteresting reds, mendoza, argentina | $37.00 |
merlot
murphy goodemerlot, california | $32.00 |
decoymerlot, california | $45.00 |
cabernet
joshcabernet, california | $32.00 |
joel gottcabernet, california | $45.00 |
rodney strong reservecabernet, sonoma, california | $75.00 |
bubbles
charles lafitte brutfrance | $9.00 |
mionetto proseccoveneto italy | $9.00 |
gh mummchampagne, france | $70.00 |
charles lafitte brutfrance | $9.00 |
mionetto proseccoveneto italy | $9.00 |
gh mummchampagne, france | - |
on tap
mango cart | $7.50 |
michelob ultra | $5.00 |
dragon point | $7.50 |
sailfish ipa | $7.50 |
caribe pineapple cider | $6.50 |
rotating selection | - |
salads
house saladromaine, tomato, red onion, cucumber, croutons, shredded blend of mozzarella & white cheddar. | $13.00 |
ceasar saladromaine, parmesan flakes, croutons, ceasar dressing | $13.00 |
house saladromaine, tomato, red onion, cucumber, croutons, shredded blend of mozzarella & white cheddar. | $13.00 |
ceasar saladromaine, parmesan flakes, croutons, ceasar dressing | $13.00 |
the cobbromaine, avocado, bacon, egg, cherry tomato, red onion, crumbled blue cheese, house blue cheese dressing | $15.00 |
grilled watermelon saladkeylime infused greek yogurt, dressed arugula, parmesan flakes, balsamic glaze | $14.00 |
grilled watermelon saladmarinated, grilled watermelon, key lime infused greek yogurt, dressed arugula, parmesan flakes, bee pollen, balsamic glaze | $14.00 |
caesar saladin house caesar, rosemary focaccia croutons, parmesan flakes | $13.00 |
bottles
budlight | $5.00 |
coors light | $5.00 |
miller lite | $5.00 |
corona | $6.00 |
high noon | $7.00 |
whites
pinot grigiogemma di luna, veneto, italy | $8.00 |
pinot grigiobarone fini, alto adige, italy | $12.00 |
sauvignon blancjoel gott, california | $10.00 |
sauvignon blanckim crawford, marlbrough, new zeland | $12.00 |
chardonnayjosh, california | $8.00 |
chardonnayrodney strong, chalk hill, california | $11.00 |
chardonnaystagsleap karia chard, napa valley, california | $75.00 |
shaken
i heard through the grapevinetito | - |
beverages
sparkling water | - |
soda | - |
apocalypse roasted coffeeespresso, latte, cappuccino | - |
cold brew | - |
iced tea | - |
arnold palmer tea | - |
sides
crispy marbled potatoes | $6.00 |
black garlic truffle fries | $6.00 |
key lime rice & grilled pineapple | $6.00 |
seasonal veggie medley | $6.00 |
garlic toast | $6.00 |
plantains | $6.00 |
tacos
chicken tacos3 chicken tacos, mojo marinated chicken, grilled flour tortilla, sofrito, romaine, house made jalapeno corn relish, cotija cheese and sriracha aioli | $14.00 |
mojo shrimp tacos3 shrimp tacos, grilled flour tortilla, superfood slaw, sweet red wine vinagrette, chipolte crema, cotija cheese | $17.00 |
fish tacos3 mahi tacos blackened or grilled, house made ponzu sauce, blend of red, green cabbage and carrots tossed in a coconut lime reduction, topped with pineapple chutney. | $15.00 |
tuna tacos3 tuna tacos served raw or seared, grilled flour tortilla, blend red, green cabbage and carrots, house made ponzu, seaweed salad | $17.00 |
appetizers
conch frittersa florida keys staple. we fry them to a crisp golden brown and serve them with a house made cajun remoulade. | $12.00 |
bahia bruschettablend of tomatoes, onion, roasted garlic and green olives, tossed in olive oil and served over grilled focaccia with fresh basil. | $12.00 |
southernmost tuna pokefresh raw tuna tossed in our house made ponzu, scallions, range, and grilled pineapple, topped with sesame seeds, and seaweed salad. served with tajin wonton crisps. | $18.00 |
alligator "death roll"eggroll stuffed with caribbean spiced alligator, superfoods slaw, fresh sweet peppers and red onion. served with tiger aioli | $16.00 |
deviled egg flightfour variations. bloody mary, avo and onion, nashville blt, devil nicoise | $14.00 |
bowls
poke bowl*fresh ahi tuna tossed in house made ponzu sauce, jasmine rice, sliced cucumber, seaweed salad, red cabbage, shredded carrots, sriracha aioli, black sesame. | $17.00 |
southeast bowlcilantro jasmine rice, avocado, sweet peppers, red onion jalapeno corn relish, diced tomato, lime, sriracha aioli. | $15.00 |
poke bowl*fresh ahi tuna tossed in house made ponzu sauce, jasmine rice, sliced cucumber, seaweed salad, red cabbage, shredded carrots, sriracha aioli, black sesame. | $17.00 |
cocktails
strawberry fieldscapri spritz tito"# handmade vodka and frth itallcus bergamotto liqueur; mlonetto strawborty emonade topped wlth drosecco prosecco frosh lemon sour club soda with etrowberty popalcle garnished with orange slice end mint sprie and eerved breakfast old fashion 14 lavender lemonade 14 russell" $ reserve small batch bourbon, tito"s handmade vodka, butterlly flowda marmalade , garnished with orange teo and housemade lavender lomonade, ovascend cherry garnished with lemon wheel sub bulldog gin for $1, | - |
morada bay mule 42martinis tito" handmade vodka , bladba irurand and fresh blackborrtes ' muddled llmo cherry good thxme 13 topped with fresh ginger beer and stoll" respberry; st-germaln eldertlower mint sprig liqueur; fresh lemon sour, garnished with lemon and thyme matecumbe malta12 papa pllar blonde rum, fresh lime espresso martini13 juice, fresh orange juice monin tito $ handmade vodke; mr; black coffee orgeat syrup; papa pilar dark rum and liqueur freshly brewed espresso, garnished wlth mint sprlg | - |
simple syrupbayside blueberry bliss martini18 fl7s 12 tito $ handmede vodke, fresh muddled our tako on classlc french 75 blueberries, simple syrup, lime egave, bulldog bin; orange marmalede ghaken and lemon sour, with & sugared rim stralned, topped wlth champagne key lime kiss martini 13 stoll" vanille, llme agave, lime in the coconut mqitc 12 monin key lime ple; coconut real, papa pilar blonde rum, real coconut pureo graham cracker rim lime wheel freph muddled mint and ilme, topped wlth soda water; smooth agave drinks conch cquntry mule 12 iatermalone 13 jameson orange, orange julce, watermelon spolon tequiim s juiceftsod wateer muddled orange and mint; iice, fresh lime juice, sode | - |
fresh @inger beerirple cactus 13 polon blanco tequlla, monin cherry iash syrup, fresh citrus pear and negranate juice, garnished with llme sy paloma 13 olon tequlla, agave syrup; llme juice, 'grapefruit julce; splash club soda, | - |
ta key marg 13ion tequlla sllver; mango purde lime julce, agave, | - |
marnler floaterss summer marg 13 n tequlla silver; watermelon julce, llme julce; agave, ed jelapelo 9 2 3 0 7 9 | $3.00 |
wine
gemma di luna - pinot grigio | $6.00 |
seaglass - riesling | $6.00 |
josh - cabernet | $6.00 |
josh - chardonnay | $6.00 |
murphy goode - merlot | $6.00 |
conundrum - red blend | $6.00 |
55 premium hjells
bahia and green olives, tossed fresh basil | $8.00 |
house made] | $58.00 |
green cabbage and ccutoeyeggroll stuffed with | $58.00 |
illigator supereoods,sh tiger aioli | $58.00 |
signaiure fries - paracsaa flake | $54.00 |
craft cocktails
watermaloneespolon silver, fresh watermelon juice, fresh lime juice, soda water | $7.00 |
purple cactusespolon blanco tequila, monin cherry smash syrup, fresh citrus pear and pomegranate juice. garnished with a lime | $7.00 |
bayside blueberry blisstitos, fresh muddled blueberries, simple syrup, lime agave, lemon sour, with a sugared rim | $7.00 |
fiesta key margespolon tequila silver, mango puree, fresh lime juice, agave, grand marnier floater | $7.00 |
endless summer margespolon tequila silver, watermelon juice, fresh lime juice, agave, muddled jalapeno | $7.00 |
strawberry fields forevertito | - |
lavender lemonadetito | - |
morada bay muletito | - |
matecumbe μαι ταιpapa pilar blonde rum, fresh lime juice, fresh orange juice, monin orgeat syrup, papa pilar dark rum, and garnished with a mint sprig | $7.00 |
lime in the coconutpapa pilar blonde rum, real coconut puree, fresh muddled mint and lime, topped with soda water | $7.00 |
cherry good thymestoli raspberry, st-germain elderflower liqueur, cherry juice, fresh lemon sour, garnished with lemon and thyme | $7.00 |
the cobb $15
romaine, avocado,bacon, egg, cherry | - |
tomato, red onion; crumbled blue | - |
cheese, house blue cheese dressing | - |
add chicken $6 shrimp $7 mahi $8 | - |
others
grilled pineapple-caipirinhacoqueiro cachaça, simple syrup, muddled with pineapple & lime | $13.00 |
cherry good thymestoli raspberry, st-germain elderflower liqueur, fresh lemon sour, garnished with lemon and thyme | $11.00 |
grilled watermelon saladkeylime infused greek yogurt, dressed arugula, parmesan flakes, balsamic glaze | $14.00 |
529 east new haven avenue | $321.00 |
conch frittersflorida keys staple served with homemade cajun remoulade | $13.00 |
ahi tuna steaky sliced ahi tuna, lightly seared,me seed, sriracha, wasabi mayo,allions, over seaweed salad | $17.00 |
Location and Hours
Discover Option Near Me
Top Restaurants
Location and Hours
Discover Option Near Me
Sharing plates of American & international fare, plus wines, cocktails & craft beer in a hip space.
$30–50
$20–30
Deli chain featuring specialty sandwiches, salads & other health-conscious fare.
$10–20
$10–20
Top Restaurants
$10–20
Copyright © 2024 - 2025 OneMenus