Florida, US

Goodfella's Pizzeria

NY-style pies & Italian chow served up in a family-friendly trattoria amid Big Apple mementos.

11873 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32826, United States

8.7

Price Per Person : $10–20

11:00 AM - 09:00 PM (Open Now)

Popular Dishes

shrimp sinatra

Shrimp • garlic • onions • bacon • creamy parmesan marinara

$21.95

shrimp parmigiana

Breaded shrimp • homemade marinara sauce • mozzarella cheese

$20.95

chicken parmigiana

Lightly breaded chicken breast tomato sauce mozzarella cheese spaghetti

$9.95

chicken antonio

Chicken cutlet ham spinach mozzarella mushroom marsala sauce over angel hair

$10.95

soup & salad

House or caesar - served with 1/2 loaf of bread

$6.95

Menu for Goodfella's Pizzeria

appetizers

baked clams our own delicious recipe. please allow extra time.	$11.95
fried calamari homemade tomato sauce	$13.95
black mussels garlic lemon white wine sauce or marinara	$11.95
cold antipasto prosciutto di parma fresh mozzarella sliced tomato	$13.95
stuffed shrimp our own delicious recipe. please allow extra time.	$13.95
baked meatballs homemade meatballs fresh spinach mozzarella cheese romano cheese	$11.95
fresh mozzarella & tomato salad fresh roma tomatoes mozzarella olive oil herbs	$10.95
tomato bruschetta toasted italian bread tomatoes mozzarella olive oil	$10.95
chicken tenders choice of sauce: plain mild medium hot bbq teriyaki	$8.95
ozzarella sticks	$8.95
arlic knots	$5.95

specialty pizza

pizza bianca no sauce • mozzarella cheese • ricotta cheese • garlic	$19.95
pizza margharita sliced tomatoes • fresh basil • olive oil	$21.95
vegetarian mozzarella • mushrooms • onions • spinach • broccoli • red peppers	$24.95
goodfella's meatlovers ham • bacon • sausage • meatball • pepperoni • cheese	$25.95
pizza primavera no sauce • mozzarella cheese • ricotta cheese • spinach • broccoli • onions • mushrooms	$22.95
shrimp & bacon shrimp • bacon • garlic • mozzarella cheese	$25.95
spinach & tomato no sauce • tomato • spinach • garlic • parmesan cheese	$22.95
hawaiian ham • pineapple	$20.95
stuffed italian pepperoni • sausage • ham • capicola • mozzarella cheese feeds 6-8 people	$44.95

salad

antipasto salad meats • cheese • lettuce • vegetables	$6.95
caesar salad \| grilled chicken caesar romaine lettuce • caesar dressing • parmesan cheese • croutons	$3.95
greek salad lettuce • vegetables • feta cheese • greek olives	$6.95
house salad	$3.95

stromboli

meatboli pepperoni bacon sausage meatballs ham mozzarella	$13.95
deluxeboli mozzarella pepperoni sausage mushrooms onions roasted red peppers	$13.95
vegiboli mozzarella spinach broccoli mushrooms onions roasted red pepper	$13.95
phillaboli mozzarella sliced steak onions mushrooms roasted red peppers	$13.95

calzone

cheese goodfella's dough • ricotta cheese • mozzarella cheese • a side of tomato sauce	$10.95
deluxe mozzarella • ricotta • pepperoni • sausage • mushrooms • onions • red peppers	$13.95
vegetarian mozzarella • ricotta • mushrooms • onions • spinach • broccoli • red peppers	$12.95
meat pepperoni • bacon • meatball • sausage • ham • mozzarella • ricotta	$13.95

wings

orlando's best chicken wings

$15.95

beverages

coke	$3.00
diet coke	$3.00
coke zero	$3.00
root beer	$3.00
raspberry tea	$3.00
lemonade	$3.00
sprite	$3.00
sweet & unsweetened iced tea	$3.00
coffee	$2.50
espresso	$3.50
cappuccino	$4.95
hot tea	$2.25
milk	$3.50
chocolate milk	$4.00
manhattan special	$4.50
san pellegrino	$3.00
apple juice	$2.50
coke	-
diet coke	-
coke zero	-
sprite	-
root beer	-
lemonade	-
sweet & unsweetened iced tea	-
raspberry tea	$2.50
coffee	$1.85
espresso	$2.95
cappuccino	$3.95
hot tea	$1.50
milk	$3.25
chocolate milk	$3.75
manhattan special	$2.50
san pellegrino	$1.95

seafood

shrimp sinatra shrimp • garlic • onions • bacon • creamy parmesan marinara	$21.95
shrimp parmigiana breaded shrimp • homemade marinara sauce • mozzarella cheese	$20.95
fresh clams fresh clams • white or red wine sauce	$18.95
zuppa di pesce fresh whole clams • mussels • shrimp • calamar • garlic • spicy marinara sauce	$23.95
seafood alfredo fresh clams • mussels • shrimp • calamari • chef's homemade alfredo sauce	$24.95
shrimp sinatra shrimp, garlic, onions, bacon, creamy parmesan marinara	$18.95
shrimp parmigiana breaded shrimp, homemade marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese	$17.95
fresh clams fresh clams, white or red wine sauce	$16.95
zuppa di pesce fresh whole clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari, garlic, spicy marinara sauce	$19.95
seafood alfredo fresh clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari, chef's homemade alfredo sauce	$19.95

soup selections

fagioli	$4.50
wedding soup	$4.50

fresh deli sabs

prosciutto di parma

fresh mozzarella & tomato

$11.95

goodfella's combination

ham - salami - capicola - pepperoni - cheese

$10.95

goodfella's pasta

tomato sauce	$11.95
marinara	$13.95
pink sauce	$14.95
meatballs	$14.95
sausage	$13.95
meat sauce	$14.95
garlic & oil	$11.95
tomato sauce	$10.95
marinara	$12.95
pink sauce	$12.95
meatballs	$12.95
sausage	$12.95
meat sauce	$12.95
garlic & oil	$11.95

premium domestic

yuengling

$4.50

white wines

chardonnay, fox hollow,ca smooth and creamy without any over bearing oak tones	$4.95
chardonnay, red diamond, wa a fruit flavored wine with aromas of apple, pear & hint of spice. great flavors of juicy honeydew melon	$22.50
pinot grigio, mezzacorona, italy this nice italian wine is dry, elegant and well balanced	$5.50
pinot grigio, ca montebello, italy this bright wine has full flavor and good balance	$29.95
riesling, columbia crest two vines, wa intense flavors of apricot and mandarin orange with great structure and balance	$5.50
white zinfandel, fox hollow, ca this wine finishes with a slightly sweet balance of raspberries and cherries	$4.95
chardonnay, fox hollow,ca smooth and creamy without any over bearing oak tones	-
chardonnay, red diamnod, wa a fruit flavored wine with aromas of apple, pear & hint of sp honeydew melon	-
pinot grigio, mezzacorona, italy this nice italian wine is dry, elegant and well balanced	-

red wines

cabernet sauvignon, fox hollow, ca a california wine with juicy plum and blackberry flavors	$29.95
cabernet sauvignon, toasted head, ca elegant and aromatic. this wine features raspberry and cherry with a hint of oak	$32.95
merlot, fox hollow, ca this wine is juicy and easy to drink	$31.95
pinot noir, mezzacorona, italy this wine is delicate and complex with very nice red fruit flavor and dry finish	$35.95
chianti, giulio stracalli, italy a bright and youthful wine with aromas of ripe red fruit and a velvety structure	$29.95
chianti classico, aziano ruffino, italy a medium bodied wine that is easy to drink with deep fruity hints of plums	$32.95
cabernet sauvignon, fox hollow, ca a california wine with juicy plum and blackberry flavors	-
cabernet sauvignon, toasted head, ca elegant and aromatic. this wine features raspberry and cherry with a hint	-
merlot, fox hollow, ca this wine is juicy and easy to drink	-
pinot noir, mezzacorona, italy this wine is delicate and complex with very nice red fruit flavor and depth	-
chianti, giulio stracalli, italy a bright and youthful wine with aromas of ripe red fruit and a velvety texture	-
chianti classico, aziano ruffino, italy a medium bodied wine that is easy to drink with deep fruity hints	-

import

peroni	$4.50
corona	-
heineken	-
stella	-

domestic

budweiser	$4.00
bud light	$4.00
amber bock	$4.00
miller lite	$4.00
michelob ultra	$4.00
coors light	$4.00

extra toppings

extra cheese	-
pepperoni	-
sausage	-
sliced meatballs	-
ham	-
bacon	-
mushrooms	-
onions	-
roasted red peppers	-
spinach	-
black olives	-
pineapple	-
broccoli	-
sliced tomatoes	-
artichoke	-
anchovies	-
garlic	-
jalapeños	-
banana peppers	-
ricotta	-
diced tomatoes	-
red peppers	-

pizza by the slice

cheese	$2.75
sicilian	$4.25

specialty slices

spinach & tomato	$3.75
stuffed italian	$8.50
bianca (white)	$3.75

pizza

cheese

$10.95

goodfella's special

pepperoni • sausage • mushrooms • onions • red pepper

$13.95

sides

side of tomato sauce	$0.75
pasta with tomato sauce	$8.95
pasta with meat sauce	$9.95
side of alfredo sauce	$5.95
side of garlic & oil	$2.00
side of pink sauce	$6.95
side of meat sauce	$5.95
meatballs	$7.95
sausage	$5.95
side of broccoli garlic & olive oil	$5.95
italian bread	$1.00
french fries	$4.95
side of tomato sauce	$0.75
pasta with tomato sauce	$7.96
pasta with meat sauce	$8.95
side of alfredo sauce	$5.00
side of garlic & oil	$1.00
side of pink sauce	$5.95
side of meat sauce	$5.95
meatballs (2)	$5.95
sausage (2)	$5.95
side of broccoli garlic & olive oil	$5.00
italian bread	$0.75
french fries	$4.50

goodfella's specialty pastas

penne a 'la vodka mushrooms • onions • peppers • creamy marinara • splash of vodka	$16.95
fettuccine alfredo fresh cream • butter • parmesan cheese	$15.95
tortellini alfredo stuffed tortellini • chef's homemade alfredo sauce	$16.95
spaghetti carbonara spaghetti • bacon • ham • onions, creamy parmesan sauce	$17.95
penne a 'la vodka mushrooms • onions • peppers • creamy marinara • splash of vodka	$14.95
fettuccine alfredo fresh cream • butter • parmesan cheese	$13.95
tortellini alfredo stuffed tortellini • chef's homemade alfredo sauce	$14.95
spaghetti carbonara spaghetti • bacon • ham • onions • creamy parmesan sauce	$15.95

chicken

antonio breaded chicken cutlet • ham • spinach • mushrooms • mozzarella • marsala wine sauce • angel hair	$19.95
parmigiana lightly breaded chicken breast • tomato sauce • mozzarella cheese • spaghetti	$16.95
marsala tender boneless chicken breast • mushroom marsala wine sauce • spaghetti	$17.95
francese lightly egg battered boneless chicken breast • butter • lemon white wine sauce • linguine	$17.95
piccata boneless chicken • lemon sauce • white wine • capers • spaghetti	$17.95
antonio breaded chicken cutlet, ham, spinach, mushrooms, mozzarella, marsala wine sauce, angel hair	$16.95
parmigiana lightly breaded chicken breast, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, spaghetti	$14.95
marsala tender boneless chicken breast, mushroom marsala wine sauce, spaghetti	$15.95
francese lightly egg battered boneless chicken breast, butter, lemon white wine sauce, linguine	$15.95
piccata boneless chicken, lemon sauce, white wine, capers, spaghetti	$15.95

daily lunch specials

2 slices cheese pizza with soup or salad	$6.95
cheese calzone with side of tomato sauce	$7.95
half sub - soup or salad sub choices - chicken - meatball or eggplant parmigiana	$7.95
italian combo foot long sub ham salami pepperoni capicola hot or cold lettuce tomato onion	$7.95
chicken parmigiana lightly breaded chicken breast tomato sauce mozzarella cheese spaghetti	$9.95
soup & salad house or caesar - served with 1/2 loaf of bread	$6.95
baked ziti with italian bread	$7.95
chicken antonio chicken cutlet ham spinach mozzarella mushroom marsala sauce over angel hair	$10.95

oven baked pasta

homemade manicotti ricotta cheese melted mozzarella cheese	$15.95
baked cheese ravioli cheese ravioli sauce melted mozzarella cheese	$14.95
goodfella's baked combo baked ziti · 1 manicotti · 2 cheese ravioli mozzarella cheese · tomato sauce	$15.95
baked trio baked manicotti · eggplant rollatini · lasagna mozzarella cheese · tomato sauce	$17.95
lasagna meat sauce · ricotta cheese · mozzarella cheese	$15.95
baked ziti ziti · ricotta · mozzarella	$13.95
homemade manicotti ricotta cheese • melted mozzarella cheese	$12.95
baked cheese ravioli cheese ravioli • sauce • melted mozzarella cheese	$12.95
goodfella's baked combo 2z - 1 manicotti • 2 cheese ravioli • mozzarella cheese • tomato sauce	$12.95
baked trio baked manicotti • eggplant rollatini • lasagna • mozzarella cheese • tomato sauce	$15.95
lasagna pasta • meat sauce • ricotta cheese • mozzarella cheese	$13.95
baked ziti ziti • ricotta • mozzarella	$12.95

hot subs

sausage, peppers & onions	$9.95
meatball parmigiana	$11.95
chicken parmigiana	$12.95
eggplant parmigiana	$11.95
veal parmigiana	$14.95
philly cheese steak	$12.95
chicken cutlet sub breaded chicken • fresh mozzarella • roasted red pepper • olive oil • basil	$13.95
sausage, peppers & onions	$9.95
meatball parmigiana	$9.95
chicken parmigiana	$10.95
eggplant parmigiana	$9.95
veal parmigiana	$11.95
philly cheese steak	$10.95
chicken cutlet sub breaded chicken fresh mozzarella roasted red pepper olive oil basil	$10.95

veal

veal parmigiana breaded veal cutlet, tomato sauce, mozzarella, spaghetti	$20.95
veal marsala veal, mushroom marsala wine sauce, spaghetti	$21.95
veal piccata tender breaded veal cutlets, capers, lemon white wine sauce, spaghetti	$21.95
veal francese lightly egg battered tender veal, butter, lemon white wine sauce, linguine	$21.95
veal parmigiana breaded veal cutler tomato sauce mozzarella spaghetti	$17.95
veal marsala veal mushroom marsala wine sauce spaghetti	$18.95
veal piccata tender breaded veal cutlets capers lemon white wine sauce spaghetti	$18.95
veal francese lightly egg battered tender veal butter lemon white wine sauce linguine	$18.95

eggplant

eggplant parmigiana fresh eggplant • tomato sauce • mozzarella cheese • spaghetti	$15.95
eggplant rollatini fresh eggplant • ricotta cheese • ham • tomato sauce • mozzarella cheese • spaghetti	$17.95
eggplant parmigiana fresh eggplant · tomato sauce · mozzarella cheese · spaghetti	$13.95
eggplant rollatini fresh eggplant · ricotta cheese · ham · tomato sauce · mozzarella cheese · spaghetti	$15.95

spaghetti with tomato sauce	$5.95
angel hair pasta with butter and parmagiana cheese	$5.49
spaghetti with meatball	$6.95
cheese ravioli	$5.95
baked ziti	$6.95
8" bambino cheese pizza (each additional topping) $.50	$6.95
chicken tenders with french fries	$6.95