Florida, US

Matanzas on the Bay

Casual eatery at Matanzas Bayside Inn with a waterfront patio, full bar & menu of pizza & seafood.

416 Crescent St, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931, United States

9.1

Price Per Person : $10–20

(Open Now)

Popular Dishes

baby back ribs

Slow roasted, sweet & spicy bbq sauce, served with one choice

$22.00

caloosa chicken

Spinach, mushroom; tomato garlic white wine, served with one choice

$18.00

snapper

Hand rolled fillets with garlic cream

$25.00

filet mignon

80z. center cut, seasoned herb butter

$37.00

flounder

Hand rolled fillets with garlic cream

$22.00

red grouper light & flaky	$30.00
mahi mahi lean & tender	$23.00
gulf shrimp locally caught	$22.00
snapper light & tender	$23.00
9 oz florida lobster tail caught in the keys	$35.00

traditional garlic cream, roasted red pepper and broccoli

$15.00

$20.00

$23.00

vz lb matanzas burger* char grilled to order 13 cheese, sauteed mushrooms or bacon +1.25 each	-
red grouper broiled, blackened, fried or signature crunchy	$21.00
shrimp burger created in our kitchen chopped shrimp, red onions, seasonings and grilled	$15.00
north atlantic cod broiled, blackened, fried or signature crunchy	$15.00

crunchy grouper seasoned corn flakes then flash fried with zesty orange dipping sauce	$30.00
seafood chimichanga shrimp, crab and monterrey cheese flash fried in a flour tortilla with creamy caliente drizzle	$18.00
coconut shrimp rum and coconut dipped, red pepper cherry jam	$23.00
in house creation hand tossed in seasoned rice crispies. red pepper cherry jam for dipping	$22.00

oven broiled in lemon wine butter	-
blackened peppery and spicy	-
fried crisp, golden brown	-
tropical pico de gallo fresh chopped	-
shrimp & basil crusted	-
savory compound butter	$2.00

red grouper house made seafood stuffing. shrimp, crab and scallops, baked au gratin with provolone and served with one choice	$32.00
gulf shrimp house made seafood stuffing. shrimp, crab and scallops, baked au gratin with provolone and served with one choice	$23.00
mahi mahi house made seafood stuffing. shrimp, crab and scallops, baked au gratin with provolone and served with one choice	$25.00
9oz lobster tail house made seafood stuffing. shrimp, crab and scallops, baked au gratin with provolone and served with one choice	$37.00
snapper hand rolled fillets with garlic cream	$25.00
flounder hand rolled fillets with garlic cream	$22.00

new york strip* 1202. center cut; seasoned herb butter	$31.00
filet mignon 80z. center cut, seasoned herb butter	$37.00
baby back ribs slow roasted, sweet & spicy bbq sauce, served with one choice	$22.00
caloosa chicken spinach, mushroom; tomato garlic white wine, served with one choice	$18.00